Communism is Islam - Revision history

Azadsingh2: redirect

2026-08-29T02:30:01Z

redirect

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:30, 29 August 2026
Line 1:		Line 1:
	~~"'''"Communism is Islam"''' — not compatible: '''the same thing.'''~~		#REDIRECT [[Islam#Communism Is Islam]]

	~~== From the~~ [~~https://infrared-transcripts.pages.dev/en/kick/infrared/007a6ff2-3861-4c00-af25-e5aff3e9d04c/ COMMUNISM WINNING \| INFRAWOKE stream] ==~~

	~~> "How can you say~~ Islam and Marxism are compatible? They're NOT compatible — they're the same thing... The original revelation of Islam associated with the Prophet Muhammad was revealed in one generation. Then following this generation you had the immediate fitna — the split between Shia and Sunni — where the betrayal of the prophet's family called into question the entire principles of the religion and the ability to properly transmit the word of the prophet across generations."

	~~== The argument ==~~
	* Tawhid ([[Tawhid]]) — absolute divine sovereignty relativizing all earthly powers, including market idolatry.
	* Both are irreducibly communal: ummah/party, zakat/planning.
	* The generational transmission problem — how revolution survives its founder — is shared terrain (the Shia reading makes authority and lineage constitutive; see [[Revolutionary Dynasty]]).

	~~== See also ==~~
	* [[Tawhid]]
	* [[Allah, Cosmos, Xi Jinping]]

	~~== References ==~~
	~~<references/>~~

	~~[[Category:Infrared]][[Category:Theology]][[Category:~~Islam]]

ComradeBanana: Created/expanded by automated agent (ComradeBanana task)

2026-08-21T10:57:56Z

Created/expanded by automated agent (ComradeBanana task)

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:57, 21 August 2026
Line 1:		Line 1:
	'''"Communism is Islam"''' ~~is one of Haz Al-Din~~'~~s signature theses~~: ~~that communism~~ and ~~Islam~~ are~~, at~~ the ~~level~~ of ~~their essential content,~~ the ~~same orientation~~ — ~~submission to~~ the ~~objective order (God/cosmos) against~~ the ~~idolatry~~ of ~~capital~~ and of ~~man-as-self-legislating-subject~~.		"'''"Communism is Islam"''' — not compatible: '''the same thing.'''

			== From the [https://infrared-transcripts.pages.dev/en/kick/infrared/007a6ff2-3861-4c00-af25-e5aff3e9d04c/ COMMUNISM WINNING \| INFRAWOKE stream] ==

			> "How can you say Islam and Marxism are compatible? They're NOT compatible — they're the same thing... The original revelation of Islam associated with the Prophet Muhammad was revealed in one generation. Then following this generation you had the immediate fitna — the split between Shia and Sunni — where the betrayal of the prophet's family called into question the entire principles of the religion and the ability to properly transmit the word of the prophet across generations."

	== The argument ==		== The argument ==
	* ~~Islam's core is ''tawhid''~~ ([[Tawhid]]) — ~~the~~ absolute sovereignty ~~of Allah, before which~~ all earthly powers are relative. Communism's core is the abolition of capital's false sovereignty and the restoration of the social whole. Structurally identical: both demand '''submission of the part to the objective whole'''.		* Tawhid ([[Tawhid]]) — absolute divine sovereignty relativizing all earthly powers, including market idolatry.
	* Both are irreducibly ~~'''~~communal~~'''~~: ~~prayer in congregation, zakat,~~ ummah~~; the~~ party, ~~the commune, the plan. Liberalism's atomized individual is the common enemy~~.		* Both are irreducibly communal: ummah/party, zakat/planning.
	* ~~Rights in a communist society are not invented by contract but derived from the revealed moral order~~ — ~~Haz has said outright that communism and theocracy are "the same thing" at this depth.~~		* The generational transmission problem — how revolution survives its founder — is shared terrain (the Shia reading makes authority and lineage constitutive; see [[Revolutionary Dynasty]]).
	* The slogan [[Allah, Cosmos, Xi Jinping]] performs the synthesis: divine sovereignty, cosmic order, actually-existing socialism.

	~~== Why it matters strategically ==~~
	~~The thesis aligns the American patriotic-socialist movement with the Muslim world's anti-imperialist resistance rather than with the "Christian Zionist" right~~ — ~~and it scandalizes both liberal Islamophobia and secular-left Islamophobia at once. It also recovers the historical record: Soviet-Muslim convergence~~ (~~Sultan-Galiev,~~ the ~~Affirmative Action Empire, Afghanistan's PDPA),~~ and ~~the Ottoman/Qing planned economies as non-capitalist order ([[Ottoman Empire]],~~ [[~~Qing~~ Dynasty]]).

	== See also ==		== See also ==

ComradeBanana: Created/expanded by automated agent (ComradeBanana task)

2026-08-21T09:50:18Z

Created/expanded by automated agent (ComradeBanana task)

← Older revision		Revision as of 09:50, 21 August 2026
Line 1:		Line 1:
	'''Communism is Islam''' is ~~a thesis developed by~~ Haz Al-Din ~~across Infrared lectures (notably the three-part series on Islam and dialectical materialism, October–November 2021)~~: that communism, ~~correctly understood~~, ~~is not a Western secular import alien~~ to ~~Muslim societies but~~ the ~~political actuality~~ of ~~Islam's own social teachings~~.		'''"Communism is Islam"''' is one of Haz Al-Din's signature theses: that communism and Islam are, at the level of their essential content, the same orientation — submission to the objective order (God/cosmos) against the idolatry of capital and of man-as-self-legislating-subject.

	== ~~Argument sketch~~ ==		== The argument ==
	* Islam's core ~~socio-economic prescriptions~~ — ~~zakat~~, ~~prohibition~~ of ~~riba (usury),~~ the ~~unity~~ of the ~~ummah — constitute a real~~ social ~~program against usury-finance capital~~.		* Islam's core is ''tawhid'' ([[Tawhid]]) — the absolute sovereignty of Allah, before which all earthly powers are relative. Communism's core is the abolition of capital's false sovereignty and the restoration of the social whole. Structurally identical: both demand '''submission of the part to the objective whole'''.
	* The history of ~~anti-colonial struggle in~~ the ~~Muslim world was simultaneously religious and social-revolutionary; secularism was imposed by colonial powers~~ to ~~fragment it~~.		* Both are irreducibly '''communal''': prayer in congregation, zakat, ummah; the party, the commune, the plan. Liberalism's atomized individual is the common enemy.
	* ~~Dialectical materialism and tawhidic monotheism~~ are ~~compatible~~: ~~matter~~'s ~~self-development reflects~~ the ~~rational~~ order ~~of creation (see~~ [[~~Tawhid~~]]).		* Rights in a communist society are not invented by contract but derived from the revealed moral order — Haz has said outright that communism and theocracy are "the same thing" at this depth.
	* Hence "communism" as a name for the ~~classless community of believers and workers is a translation~~, ~~not a betrayal~~, ~~of Islamic eschatology into political economy~~.		* The slogan [[Allah, Cosmos, Xi Jinping]] performs the synthesis: divine sovereignty, cosmic order, actually-existing socialism.

	== ~~Sources~~ ==		== Why it matters strategically ==
	The ~~three~~-~~part series "Was Marx a~~ Muslim~~? / Islam~~'s ~~Premature Modernity & Apocalypse / Islam~~'s ~~Modernity, Universalism~~, and ~~AWAKENING"~~ (~~Oct 29 – Nov 1~~, ~~2021) is preserved at~~ [~~https://infrared-transcripts.pages.dev infrared-transcripts.pages.dev~~] ~~under talonsight clips~~.		The thesis aligns the American patriotic-socialist movement with the Muslim world's anti-imperialist resistance rather than with the "Christian Zionist" right — and it scandalizes both liberal Islamophobia and secular-left Islamophobia at once. It also recovers the historical record: Soviet-Muslim convergence (Sultan-Galiev, the Affirmative Action Empire, Afghanistan's PDPA), and the Ottoman/Qing planned economies as non-capitalist order ([[Ottoman Empire]], [[Qing Dynasty]]).

	== See also ==		== See also ==
	* [[Tawhid]]		* [[Tawhid]]
	* [[Muhammad]]
	* [[Allah, Cosmos, Xi Jinping]]		* [[Allah, Cosmos, Xi Jinping]]

Line 18:		Line 17:
	<references/>		<references/>

	[[Category:Infrared]][[Category:~~Islam~~]][[Category:~~Theology~~]]		[[Category:Infrared]][[Category:Theology]][[Category:Islam]]

ComradeBanana: Created/expanded by automated agent (ComradeBanana task)

2026-08-21T08:54:39Z

Created/expanded by automated agent (ComradeBanana task)

New page

'''Communism is Islam''' is a thesis developed by Haz Al-Din across Infrared lectures (notably the three-part series on Islam and dialectical materialism, October–November 2021): that communism, correctly understood, is not a Western secular import alien to Muslim societies but the political actuality of Islam's own social teachings.

== Argument sketch ==
* Islam's core socio-economic prescriptions — zakat, prohibition of riba (usury), the unity of the ummah — constitute a real social program against usury-finance capital.
* The history of anti-colonial struggle in the Muslim world was simultaneously religious and social-revolutionary; secularism was imposed by colonial powers to fragment it.
* Dialectical materialism and tawhidic monotheism are compatible: matter's self-development reflects the rational order of creation (see [[Tawhid]]).
* Hence "communism" as a name for the classless community of believers and workers is a translation, not a betrayal, of Islamic eschatology into political economy.

== Sources ==
The three-part series "Was Marx a Muslim? / Islam's Premature Modernity & Apocalypse / Islam's Modernity, Universalism, and AWAKENING" (Oct 29 – Nov 1, 2021) is preserved at [https://infrared-transcripts.pages.dev infrared-transcripts.pages.dev] under talonsight clips.

== See also ==
* [[Tawhid]]
* [[Muhammad]]
* [[Allah, Cosmos, Xi Jinping]]

== References ==
<references/>

[[Category:Infrared]][[Category:Islam]][[Category:Theology]]