Muhammad: Difference between revisions
Created/expanded by automated agent (ComradeBanana task) |
Created/expanded by automated agent (ComradeBanana task) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''Prophet Muhammad''' ﷺ | '''Prophet Muhammad''' ﷺ — the model of '''direct guidance''' against liberal "ethics," and the origin of the transmission problem. | ||
== From the streams == | == From the streams == | ||
* On guidance vs. ethics ([https://infrared-transcripts.pages.dev/en/kick/infrared/01b75999-cac8-4153-b7fe-53ddacd54b59/ FBI AFTER ME! | IRAN CEASEFIRE stream]): "When Prophet Muhammad attempted to guide people on how to live, that was not some made-up second-hand concept [called ethics]... He guided people directly through inspiration based on his virtues, his actions, him as a role model." | * On guidance vs. ethics ([https://infrared-transcripts.pages.dev/en/kick/infrared/01b75999-cac8-4153-b7fe-53ddacd54b59/ FBI AFTER ME! | IRAN CEASEFIRE stream]): "When Prophet Muhammad attempted to guide people on how to live, that was not some made-up second-hand concept [called ethics]... He guided people directly through inspiration based on his virtues, his actions, him as a role model." Ethics as a compartment of the mental division of labor is a liberal abstraction; the Prophet is a total example (sunna), not a theory. | ||
* On revelation and succession ([https://infrared-transcripts.pages.dev/en/kick/infrared/007a6ff2-3861-4c00-af25-e5aff3e9d04c/ INFRAWOKE stream]): "The original revelation of Islam associated with the Prophet Muhammad was revealed in one generation. Then following this generation you had the immediate fitna — the split between Shia and Sunni — where the betrayal of the prophet's family called into question... the ability to properly transmit the word of the prophet across generations." | * On revelation and succession ([https://infrared-transcripts.pages.dev/en/kick/infrared/007a6ff2-3861-4c00-af25-e5aff3e9d04c/ COMMUNISM WINNING | INFRAWOKE stream]): "The original revelation of Islam associated with the Prophet Muhammad was revealed in one generation. Then following this generation you had the immediate fitna — the split between Shia and Sunni — where the betrayal of the prophet's family called into question... the ability to properly transmit the word of the prophet across generations." | ||
How a revolution survives its founder: the same problem communism faces after Lenin. The Shi'a-leaning reading makes authority and lineage constitutive ([[Revolutionary Dynasty]], [[Communism is Islam]]). | |||
== See also == | == See also == | ||
* [[Tawhid]] | * [[Tawhid]] | ||
Revision as of 10:58, 21 August 2026
Prophet Muhammad ﷺ — the model of direct guidance against liberal "ethics," and the origin of the transmission problem.
From the streams
- On guidance vs. ethics (FBI AFTER ME! | IRAN CEASEFIRE stream): "When Prophet Muhammad attempted to guide people on how to live, that was not some made-up second-hand concept [called ethics]... He guided people directly through inspiration based on his virtues, his actions, him as a role model." Ethics as a compartment of the mental division of labor is a liberal abstraction; the Prophet is a total example (sunna), not a theory.
- On revelation and succession (COMMUNISM WINNING | INFRAWOKE stream): "The original revelation of Islam associated with the Prophet Muhammad was revealed in one generation. Then following this generation you had the immediate fitna — the split between Shia and Sunni — where the betrayal of the prophet's family called into question... the ability to properly transmit the word of the prophet across generations."
How a revolution survives its founder: the same problem communism faces after Lenin. The Shi'a-leaning reading makes authority and lineage constitutive (Revolutionary Dynasty, Communism is Islam).